Magazine · 5 min read

Replacement car after an accident: who pays? Austria’s Variante A explained

Tyroldrive replacement car arriving at the car park, the customer waves

After an accident, your car is in the workshop and you still need one. Many people assume that the other party’s insurer will pay for the hire car. In Austria that is often not the case, and the reason is called Variante A. Here you can read what lies behind it, when someone does pay after all and what to do after an accident.

What Variante A is

Almost all drivers in Austria have taken out their third-party liability insurance as Variante A, because the premium is then around 20 to 25% cheaper. In return, you waive compensation for hire car costs from the other car’s insurer, driver and owner. According to Autorevue, the waiver also covers loss of earnings.

It is based on an agreement among all Austrian insurers. Austria’s Supreme Court has ruled that this so-called split tariff is not unconscionable. The result: even if the other party was at fault, you usually pay for the replacement car yourself.

Whether you have Variante A is stated in your policy. If in doubt, ask your insurer or broker.

When the other party pays after all

The waiver only applies to vehicles with compulsory insurance in Austria. In these cases, the other party’s insurer pays for the hire car for the duration of the repair, if the other party was at fault:

  • The other party is driving a car with foreign plates. In Tyrol, with plenty of holiday and through traffic, this is often the case.
  • The other party is a cyclist or pedestrian.
  • It was a tram.
  • It was a construction vehicle or a slow vehicle that cannot go faster than 10 km/h.

Who else might pay

Even with Variante A, you don’t always have to pay for the replacement car yourself. Check these options:

  • Comprehensive insurance: depending on the policy, hire car costs are covered for a few days.
  • Breakdown cover: the ÖAMTC Schutzbrief pays for onward travel or the journey home after a breakdown or accident while travelling, by replacement car or by train and bus. On top of that come a taxi up to €50 and up to three nights at a maximum of €85 each.
  • Assistance and mobility guarantee: many packages, for example from ÖAMTC or ARBÖ, or the mobility guarantee with a lease pay for a replacement car for a few days.
  • Company car: with lease and fleet contracts, the contract determines whether a replacement vehicle is included.
  • Workshop: some workshops give regular customers a courtesy car cheaply or free of charge. Ask before you place the order.

Who pays for what? An overview

This is usually how it works for cars insured in Austria, if the other party caused the accident:

SituationWho usually pays for the replacement car
Other party insured in Austria, you have Variante AYou yourself, unless comprehensive cover, breakdown cover or the workshop step in
Other party with foreign platesThe other party’s insurer, for the duration of the repair
Accident with a cyclist, pedestrian or tramThe other party or their insurer
BreakdownBreakdown cover or assistance, depending on the policy, otherwise you yourself
Company or leased carDepends on the lease or fleet contract

Every case and every policy is different. This overview is not legal advice. ÖAMTC members can get free legal advice there.

Paying yourself: what matters

If nobody pays, what counts is the daily rate and how flexible you are. At Tyroldrive we tell you the daily rate straight away on the phone, including mileage and vignette. You only pay for the days you need and extend day by day, simply via WhatsApp.

Where possible, you get a car equivalent to your own. That also matters to the insurer, in case it does pay after all.

After an accident: step by step

To make sure everything is clear later, proceed as follows after an accident:

  • Secure the scene: hazard lights on, put on a high-visibility vest, set up the warning triangle.
  • If anyone is injured, call the emergency services immediately: ambulance 144 or European emergency number 112.
  • If anyone is injured or it’s unclear who is at fault, call the police (133); otherwise fill in the accident report together.
  • Take photos of the scene and the damage, and exchange details with everyone involved.
  • Inform your insurer and ask whether it will pay for a replacement car.
  • Call us: we’ll bring the replacement car to wherever you need it.
Driver checking the engine compartment after a breakdown

How Tyroldrive helps

You don’t need an accident report or police report for the rental, but you do for the insurer. Keep both safe, along with photos, the workshop invoice and the invoice for the replacement car.

We’re available around the clock, including nights, weekends and public holidays. We bring the replacement car to the garage, your home, your office or the accident scene. Delivery is free in Innsbruck, and anywhere in Tyrol, for example Hall, Schwaz, Wörgl, Imst, Landeck or Kitzbühel, costs €2.50 per kilometre from our base.

All our rental cars have automatic transmission, winter tyres in winter and the Austrian motorway vignette. So you’re mobile again straight away, for work or personal use.

Frequently asked questions

What does Variante A mean for third-party liability insurance?

With Variante A, you pay a lower premium and in return waive compensation for hire car costs from the other party’s insurer, if the other party has compulsory insurance in Austria. Almost all third-party liability policies in Austria are Variante A.

Will my insurance pay for the replacement car?

That depends on your policy. In Austria, most liability policies are "Variant A" with a rental car waiver: you then pay for the replacement car yourself, even if the other driver was at fault. Exceptions include an accident with a foreign-registered vehicle, a cyclist, a pedestrian or a tram. Comprehensive cover, breakdown cover or an assistance package often pay for a few days.

Do I need an accident report or a police report?

Not for the rental, but yes for the insurance. Keep both safe.

How much does a replacement car cost per day?

We’ll tell you straight away on the phone, including mileage and vignette. You only pay for the days you need.

Can my garage take delivery of the replacement car?

Yes, we deliver straight to the garage and collect the car from there too.

← Back to the magazine
Tyroldrive rental cars by a mountain lake in Tyrol
Colourful houses on the Inn in Innsbruck with the Nordkette
Tyroldrive Mercedes-Benz C-Class in front of mountain peaks in Tyrol
Tyroldrive Peugeot 308 SW in front of the mountains in Tyrol

Tyrol is waiting. So is your hire car.

Booked in a few minutes. We bring the car, you drive off.

Snow-covered mountain village in the Alps
Book now